Cross Origin Resource Sharing (CORS) best practices
Free for all
A common example is if you own a website that displays content for the public, that is not behind paywalls, or requiring authentication or authorization – you should be able to set Access-Control-Allow-Origin: * to its resources.
The * value is a good choice in cases when:
No authentication or authorization is required
The resource should be accessible to a wide range of users without restrictions
The origins & clients that will access the resource is of great variety, you don’t have knowledge of it or you simply don’t care
A dangerous prospect of such configuration is when it comes to content served on private networks (i.e. behind firewall or VPN). When you are connected via a VPN, you have access to the files on the company’s network:
Oversimplification of VPNs
Now, if an attacker hosts as website dangerous.com, which contains a link to a file within the VPN, they can (in theory) create a script on their website that can access that file:
While such an attack is hard and requires a lot of knowledge about the VPN and the files stored within it, it is a potential attack vector that we must be aware of.
Keeping it in the family
Continuing with the example from above, imagine we want to implement analytics for our website. We would like our users' browsers to send us data about the experience and behavior of our users on our website.
In such cases, our API is public, but we don’t want any website to send data to our analytics API. In fact, we are interested only in requests that originate from browsers that have our website rendered – that is all.
In such cases, we want our API to set the Access-Control-Allow-Origin header to our website’s URL. That will make sure browsers never send requests to our API from other pages.
If users or other websites try to cram data in our analytics API, the Access-Control-Allow-Origin headers set on the resources of our API won’t let the request to go through:
In such cases, if our servers do now allow access to resources for the null origin, then it can be a hindrance to the developer productivity. Allowing the null origin within your CORS policy has to be deliberately done, and only if the users of your website / product are developers.
Skip cookies, if you can
As we saw before with the Access-Control-Allow-Credentials, cookies are not enabled by default. To allow cross-origin sending cookies, it as easy as returning Access-Control-Allow-Credentials: true. This header will tell browsers that they are allowed to send credentials (i.e. cookies) in cross-origin requests.
Allowing and acepting cross-origin cookies can be tricky. You could expose yourself to potential attack vectors, so enable them only when absolutely neccessary.
Cross-origin cookies work best in situations when you know exactly which clients will be accessing your server. That is why the CORS semantics do not allow us to set Access-Control-Allow-Origin: * when cross-origin credentials are allowed.
While the Access-Control-Allow-Origin: * and Access-Control-Allow-Credentials: true combination is technically allowed, it’s a anti-pattern and should absolutely be avoided.
If you would like your servers to be accessed by different clients and origins, you should probably look into building an API (with token-based authentication) instead of using cookies. But if going down the API path is not an option, then make sure you implement cross-site request forgery (CSRF) protection.
Post a Comment